The Blog for Otego, New YorkPosts RSS Comments RSS

Archive for the 'Natural Gas Drilling in the Marcellus Shale' Category

Clean Natural Gas is a Lie

Well of course it’s a lie. It’s a euphemism for “Not as dirty as the dirtiest thing there is.” Even “Relatively cleaner,” would be a lie. “Less dirty” does not mean “clean”. “Less black” does not mean “white”, and “less evil” does not mean “good,” unless you are a mealy-mouthed apologist waiting for a corporate handout from an industry you otherwise consider corrupt and dishonest.

It’s just a dirty (not “less clean”) tactic of a filthy industry.

Beyond that, here’s news about how truly dirty natural gas is:

According to Newswise:

Extracting natural gas from the Marcellus Shale could do more to aggravate global warming than mining coal, according to a Cornell study published in the May issue of the peer-reviewed journal Climatic Change Letters.

I expect that the typical disingenuous arguments will be made against this study, such as, “There’s no such thing as global warming. It’s all a liberal conspiracy – the space aliens in my attic told me so,” etc.

No responses yet

Petition to Prohibit Heavy Industry in the Town of Otego

The Concerned Citizens of Otego have drafted a petition to prohibit heavy industry, like that of gas drilling, in the Town of Otego. Here is the wording:

We, the undersigned, request the Otego Town Board to pass legislation prohibiting heavy industry in the town of Otego (including hydraulic fracturing for natural gas).

Our concerns include the protection of health, resources, property values, traditional businesses, and the natural beauty of our community.

We, the undersigned, are concerned citizens who urge our leaders to act now to pass an ordinance to prohibit heavy industry in our community.

If you are a resident of the Town of Otego (which includes the Village of Otego), please sign the petition.

(Wait for it to load – it could take a few seconds.)

3 responses so far

Is Drilling for Natural Gas Good for your Community?

This information was put together by the Concerned Citizens of Otego. You can download it as a tri-fold brochure by right-clicking on “Effects of Natural Gas Drilling.”

Otego Before and after Horizontal Fracking for Natural Gas?

Otego before and after horizontal fracking for natural gas?

Click Here to Sign the petition against Drilling for Natural Gas in Otego

 

How will natural gas drilling affect my health?

Continue Reading »

No responses yet

What the FRACK?

This is a guest-post by a high-school student who writes for “The Whisk,” (Motto: “Society is like a stew. If you don’t stir it up every once in a while then a layer of scum floats to the top.”- Edward Abbey) a high-school newspaper from a school near Boston.

The reason I want to include it is because it’s refreshing to see young people think in such a good, logical way, and not be swayed by labeling and ad hominem attacks.

To that effect, I also want to include the brilliant introduction to the first issue of “The Whisk” before the article about fracking.

Introduction – So what the heck is this?

This is a new publication from your peers here at GHS, dedicated to all things environmentally and socially progressive. Not really though. Wait, what?

You see, in this hyper-everything world that we live in, the public’s attention span is widely accepted to be quite short. Like many widely accepted things, this may not be true. But what is true is that most media and other such things in our current culture assume that this is the case; that our attention spans don’t span more than a few seconds at best. Hence, we see the use of quick words and phrases that are meant to sum up grand concepts. There is a prevailing black and white mentality, a whose-side-are-you-on, contentious mindset that fosters ill will and misunderstanding.

You are no doubt keenly aware of this. High school is one of the most concentrated places of this culture. If you dress “this” way and hang out with “these” people, then you must be “that”. This seems to carry on into the adult world, where nearly everyone is likely to be pulled into some sort of faction in the minds of others. A Democrat has to like bigger government, unions and protecting the environment. A Republican must be for smaller government, abolition of unions and corporate interests. No doubt, you are sure to find a democrat and a republican who do those things. But not all. There are democrats who are not for larger government. There are even Republicans who are for the environment! They’re called Republicans for Environmental Protection. Their slogan has a green elephant, and they operate under the motto “there’s nothing more conservative than conservation”.

The point trying to be made here is that we can’t allow labeling. We can’t content ourselves with breaking things down to their bare minimum. We have to read the facts and not the opinions. Our opinions should be our own. It may be hard to follow something that you believe when it goes against the beliefs of those around you. But we urge you to make that jump. We live in the United States! It is still our right, for the most part, to think and say and be what we feel like.

So is the whisk a hippie publication bent on infecting your soul, curving your spine and keeping the country from winning the war (to phrase from the late, great George Carlin)? Some articles might be. But that doesn’t make the entire publication such. The Whisk is not radical. It is a zine meant to call to your attention what is too often lacking in this hectic world of ours: logic. Common sense. Coming from the Environmental Club, one might say that this is biased. It’s not! In the words on one Edward Abbey: “Reason has seldom failed us because it has seldom been tried.” An environmentalist might support the shift to natural gas for our energy needs.

Someone applying reason might look at the process this entails, and the destruction and pollution it renders upon the earth, and conclude otherwise.

The Whisk seeks to try reason. Please be skeptical of everything you read here, or anywhere for that matter, that is not explicitly presented as a fact. Then, if so inclined, we encourage you to look things up for yourself. The Internet rocks. So read on with one eyebrow raised, and become a part of our little movement to eradicate ignorance, prejudice, fanaticism, pretentiousness and all such mean nasty things.

 

What the FRACK?

By Sylvia Wilde

As the carbon fuels that we’ve used to restructure the Earth’s atmosphere and ravage its climate begin to dwindle, coal, oil, and gas companies are scrambling to tear every last bit of fossil fuel out of the ground–as violently as necessary. Coal companies are blowing up mountains for thin seams of coal, oil companies are denuding thousands of square miles of land to get at tar sands, and natural gas companies are fracking.

Fracking, or hydraulic fracturing for natural gas, is the method used to release pockets of methane from a type of rock–such as shale–that is particularly impermeable. The process goes like this:
Gas companies will drill a well deep underground to the rock where the methane deposits are. Then, they will pump a mixture of sand, water, and other chemicals into the ground at such a high pressure that the bedrock cracks. When it does, the sand in the mixture fills the cracks, holding them open and allowing the gas to finally seep out.

This process wastes staggering amounts of water–millions of gallons for each frack–but it has the potential to pollute far more. Hundreds of tons of volatile organic compounds are used each time a well is fractured, and many of these compounds are carcinogens (cancer causers) or endocrine disruptors, which are chemicals that throw off our body chemistry by mimicking our hormones. When the casings to the wells leak, they release water contaminated with gas and toxic chemicals into the water table. Fracking has been linked to over 1,000 instances of contaminated drinking water, and some people have even had water coming out of their faucet that was flammable because of the methane in it.

So how are they getting away with this? The energy policy act of 2005 created a loophole for frackers that exempted them from the Safe Drinking Water Act and other EPA-enforced laws. Now the gas companies don’t even have to tell what chemicals they’re putting into their fracking fluid.  That means, even when there is proven water contamination, it can’t necessarily be traced back to the frackers.

All of this is starting to get a lot scarier for those of us who live out east. Companies like Halliburton have been fracking for years in western states like Colorado and Wyoming, but now they’re invading states like Pennsylvania and New York so that they can exploit the vast Marcellus Shale that lies beneath them. It’s time to get angry.

Right now, the battle over what gas companies are going to be able to do is being waged on both a state and national level. Last November, the people of New York State made a stand and put a freeze on all fracking in their state; they were unwilling to watch the NYC’s water be contaminated by corporate greed. This is a good first step, but we can’t stop here: if we’re going to protect our health and our environment, we can’t be apathetic, we need to act now.

Here’s what you can do:

1) Tell your friends and family about hydraulic fracturing and why it’s so fracking stupid.

2) Call, email, or write to your senators and your representative in congress, asking them to cosponsor The FRAC Act, H.R. 2766 or  S. 1215, which would hold natural gas companies accountable under the Safe Drinking Water act and force them to tell what chemicals they’re fracking with.

3)Learn more by going to http://earthworksaction.org/FracingDetails.cfm, gaslandthemovie.com, or the website of a trusted organization.

 Don’t let them frack our future!

No responses yet

Natural Gas Boomtown News

Have you been doubting the myth that natural gas brings good things to communities? So have most people. Here is some hard evidence that the “Boomtown Mentality” is not all it’s cracked up to be:

Energy Boomtowns & Natural Gas: Implications for Marcellus Shale Local Governments & Rural Communities

From NERCRD Rural Development Paper No. 43 January 2009, 63 pp. Prepared by Jeffrey Jacquet
Here’s the table of contents:

Part One: The Boomtown Impact Model

  • The Boomtown Narrative
  • Challenges to Local Governments
  • Government and Community Reaction to Boomtown Growth
  • Economic Impacts
  • Social Impacts
  • Criticisms of the model
  • The Bust

Part Two: The Case Study of Sublette County Wyoming

  • Historical and Cultural Context
  • Employment and Demographic
  • Impacts Impacts to Economic Activity
  • Impacts to Local Governments
  • Social Impacts Fit to the Boomtown Model

Part Three: Implications for the Marcellus Shale:
The Recent Demand for Natural Gas Drilling
Applicability of Marcellus Shale Development to the Boomtown Model
Implications for Local Government and Communities

 

Download Energy Boomtowns & Natural Gas here (right click).

 

Thanks to Roz Shafer for pointing me to this.

 

Have you read this Sunday’s NY Times? Front page: Regulation Lax as Gas Wells’ Tainted Water Hits Rivers

Already the shills for the gas industry have mobilized with dubious critiques and half-truths to “debunk” the well-researched and devastating article in the NYT. The coalitions are showing their desperation.

Fortunately, the NYT is keeping up with reporting the truth, and has a fine rebuttal to the gas coalition’s baloney today.

One response so far

The Gift of the Coalitions

You may want to consider that the word “gift” means “poison” in at least one language.

This wonderfully written parody of “A Visit from Saint Nick”  (original by Clement Clarke Moore in 1823) was written by Yvonne M. Lucia in December of 2010. If anyone knows how t reach Yvonne, please let me know. It was circulated in an e-mail that I got, probably about fourth-hand.


‘Twas the night before Christmas, when all through the state,
the citizens were restless, awaiting their fate.
FONG* signs were placed on front lawns with care,
in hopes that gas drilling would commence there.

Leaseholders were nestled, all snug in their beds,
while visions of a gold rush danced in their heads.
With Cuomo in Albany and Pete Grannis gone,
will our leaders become industry’s pawn?

In Dimock , PA there’s been such a clatter -
the water’s gone bad, but what does it matter?
In Big Flats, NY people’s water is bubbling;
there’s no fracking yet , that’s what’s most troubling.

Gas flares on the breast of the new fallen snow
gave a luster of orange to objects below,
when what to our wondering eyes should appear,
but water trucks, rigs, and compressor stations near,

and armies of landmen, who bold-face lies speak;
we knew in a moment they’re from Chesapeake .
They descended like vultures circling their prey,
from farmers to widows, they promised to pay

fifty dollars an acre, now one hundred, now two,
up to one thousand, six thousand, it’s true!
“To the top of the heap! Don’t let the deal stall!
Now sign the lease! Sign the lease! Sign the lease, all!”

When permits were granted, along came denials
that there could be problems with drilling gone wild.
As gag rules were issued when water went bad,
people began to feel they’d been had.

So they joined forces and shared their sad tales -
in state after state, regulations had failed.
They held their heads high and spoke truth to power:
“This is the moment, this is the hour -

We demand our right to clean water and air,
to the seventh generation we pledge our care;
not in my backyard, or in anyone else’s
will we ravage the earth to fatten our purses.”

Their eyes, how they twinkled, their spirits were merry!
Onward and upward their voices did carry.
In spite of the obstacles, grass roots groups formed;
Now thousands strong, gas companies, be warned:

“You are NOT persons, despite what courts say.
We the people will have our way
as we take back our land, our water and air,
our victories won on a wing and a prayer.”

And then in that instant, up on the roof
we heard someone crying, we needed no proof.
As we drew in our heads and were turning around,
down the chimney St. Nicholas came with a bound.

His eyes were all bloodshot, but not from not sleeping;
“Oh Santa, dear Santa Claus, why are you weeping?”
“High up in the sky my sleigh has been flying;
when I looked down below, I saw the earth dying.

My heart is breaking, there’ll be Christmas no more
if in place of giving, greed is the lure.”
And we heard him exclaim as he drove out of sight,
“Drilling isn’t safe – keep up the fight!”

(*FONG =Friends of Natural Gas)

One response so far

Dirty Rotten Scoundrels

Hard to be civil when you’re dealing with lying thieves.


Read: Marcellus Shale: The Real Price of Compulsory Integration In New York


No responses yet

DEC commissioner Pete Grannis fired

Department of Environmental Conservation Commissioner Pete Grannis hasn’t actually been doing a brilliant job of protecting NY State from the predatory Natural Gas Industry, but even though he is not a strong link, he was a link. But now the Governor Paterson has been convinced to even can him for the absurdly trumped-up charge of “insubordination.”

Yeah, he had the guts to say that the recent layoffs of over 200 DEC staff would seriously weaken the agency’s ability to protect New York’s environment. But who the hell cares about heath, safety, quality of life or the environment, when there are the profits of parasitic out-of-state corporations and their suck-ups to protect?

This from the Adironack Daily Enterprise:

“Many of our programs are hanging by a thread,” stated the memo, which was reported by the Albany Times Union on Tuesday. “The public would be shocked to learn how thin we are in many areas. DEC is in the weakest position that it has been since it was created 40 years ago.”

The memo warned that fewer polluted sites would be cleaned, stocking of game fish could be halted, and fewer regulators would be available to oversee the expected natural gas drilling boom in the Marcellus Shale that extends into southern New York.

So much for the the gas pusher’s claims that “You have to let the DEC do their jobs.” There go over 200 more DEC jobs that won’t be done.

It’s strange (but sadly predictable) that there will always be a portion of the population that will be fooled by people who see black as white, wrong as right (as well as  horizontal as vertical.) At every meeting where there have been pro-gas proponents, I’ve heard, “NY has the most regulations, staff, blah, blah, blah…” But we know that these are the same people who want to reduce that.

What was meager before is being reduced to woefully insufficient.

It’s no comfort to me and other anti-fracking people to know that all the pro-gas folks will regret what they are proposing some time in the future. I wish they could see that it’s not worth selling out now for a promise. But many people just don’t really think or care about the future, or the consequences of an irrational belief in “free money.”

Read the coverage at the Albany Times Union.

Take action!

This is from an e-mail from Walter Hang. It’s

Call and email Paterson to decry his efforts to cut critical environmental and health regulatory programs. Gutting DEC makes a mockery of his promise to make sure Marcellus Shale Gas Hydrofracking is done safely.  This is the last straw. Demand the draft SGEIS to be withdrawn.  Pour it on.  This is a golden opportunity.

Governor David Paterson

  • Please bcc: info@toxicstargeting.com so we can maintain a record of all contacts.
  • One response so far

    From the Liar’s Playbook

    In an article today in the Charlotte Observer, Piedmont Natural Gas chief shill Thomas Skains insists on peddling the hokum of natural gas as “clean energy.”

    Some of his more dubious (devious) statements from the article are mentioned below.

    “Q: Given the explosion in California, how do we know our pipelines are safe?

    “A: Our pipelines are safe.”

    In other words, “Because I said so!” Which basically means, “This is not true.”

    “This is nothing new. Hydraulic fracturing has been deployed over 60 years in more than 1 million wells, and I’m told there hasn’t been a single incident of proof that there’s been any groundwater contamination.”

    OK, these are just lies. This man apparently does not know, or is lying about the difference between vertical and horizontal, which is just another part of the playbook of this predatory industry. This is ENTIRELY new.

    High-density, high-pressure, horizontal hydraulic fracturing has NOT been done for over 60 years. He is comparing vertical to horizontal fracking, and that is like comparing the Wright Brothers’ plane with the SST.

    It is disingenuous spin, which further proves that the representatives of this industry should not be trusted further than you can spit a rat.

    As far as he’s been “told” that there hasn’t been a single incidence of proof… yeah, if you only listen to the other shills, you won’t get honest information. The truth is that we probably never will be told of the incidents, because the industry puts so much effort into covering everything up and lobbying for deregulation and tax breaks. It’s guys like him who don’t want you to know when their industry screws up, so why on earth would anybody trust him or quote him without challenging it?

    No responses yet

    DELAWARE COUNTY ANTI-GAS DRILLING MARCH & RALLY

    JOIN US!

    DELAWARE COUNTY ANTI-GAS DRILLING MARCH & RALLY Delhi, NY

    Wednesday, September 8, 2010

    5:00 to 6:00 p.m.

    in front of the County Office Building, 111 Main St.

    as the Delaware County Board of Supervisors arrive for their monthly meeting.

    JOIN US! an ad hoc group of Delaware County residents

    who rally in Delhi to ask…..

    Gas Drilling?

    Who REALLY Wins? Who REALLY Loses?


    • JOIN US! if you are one of the majority of NEW YORKERS (53% in a recent Cornell University poll) who now see MORE RISK THAN REVENUE in the Gas Drilling Scam!
    • JOIN US! if you are concerned about the wanton carelessness of a drilling industry that reneges on its promises to communities while it spills and contaminates across the country!
    • JOIN US! if you think the tax payer will be left to live with TOXIC WASTE, AIR & WATER POLLUTION, ILLNESS.
    • JOIN US! if you are concerned that while A VERY FEW will profit, THE REST OF US will lose our way of life and be in debt for the mess the drillers will leave us!
    • JOIN US! if you are concerned that our County Board of Supervisors supports drilling – WITHOUT HEARING BOTH SIDES OF THE ISSUE!
    • JOIN US! to demand that time be allotted for Delaware County Citizens to be heard at all Delaware County Supervisors’ meetings!
    • JOIN US! if you want your voice to be heard.

    There will be a microphone & loudspeaker available.

    Anyone wishing to speak may do so for 2 minutes.

    PLEASE ARRIVE BY 4:30 TO SIGN UP TO SPEAK.

    Sponsored by:

    The Sept. 8 Rally & Protest Committee

    • ANDES:  Judy Garrison;  BOVINA: Heidi Gogins,  Michael Gogins;
    • COLCHESTER: Caroline Martin, Deborah Rivers; DAVENPORT: Eleanor Moriarty;
    • DEPOSIT:  Kathleen Livington, Stan Salthe;
    • DELHI:  Faiga Brussel,  Nancy Fales Garrett,  Jessica Vecchione;
    • FRANKLIN:  Fokish Farm (Katarina Isaksson & Hank Stahler), Carole Marner, Gene Marner, Carolyn C. Pierson, Walter Putrycz, Ellen Sokolow;
    • HAMDEN:  Leslie Albaugh,  Nick Albaugh, Judith Lamb, Robert Reiter,  Linda Stephan;
    • HANCOCK:  Jannette Barth,  Dolores Bentham,  Beat Keerl,  Talia Lugacy,  Tom Noonan,
    • HARPERSFIELD: Louise von Brockdorff
    • KORTRIGHT: Carl Arnold;   MASONVILLE:  Kathleen Klopchin;
    • MEREDITH:  Harry Barnes,  Amy Weiss Friedman, Muffy McDowell, John Ryan, Kate Ryan, Joan Tubridy, Marguerite Uhlmann-Bower,  Aldine Weiss;
    • TOMPKINS: Linda Daly, Tom Daly, Steve Dungan;
    • WALTON: Dave Baker, Naomi Fisch, Deborah Hunt, Stony Creek Farm (Dan & Kate Marsiglio)


    2 responses so far

    « Prev - Next »